Welcome to Joey Garlic's Newington
Joey Garlic's Newington, located at 150 Kitts Ln, is a beloved Italian eatery known for its exceptional flavors and generous portions. Customers rave about the deliciousness of every dish, from the highly-praised eggplant parm grinder to the standout pasta selections that remind many of family recipes. The restaurant boasts a pleasant ambiance, with spacious seating and a knowledgeable staff eager to enhance your dining experience. While some reviews mention minor miss on side dishes, the overall consensus is that the quality of food—especially the gluten-free pizza—is worth every penny. Whether it's a casual outing or a special celebration, Joey Garlic's promises memorable meals in a welcoming environment.
Joey Garlic's Newington: Reviews & Ratings
Love this place!! I never had a bad menu item. Everything is always delicious. I recently had the eggplant parm grinder and it was very tasty! I recommend eating here if you haven't yet.
Highly recommend, I love their portions. Their pasta is amazing, especially being raised in an Italian family it is very good. The price is expensive but I do think it is worth it. BOOK AHEAD, you will be waiting a while especially on the weekend. The only thing that was alittle bland was the broccoli and cheddar soup. Other than that, I will continue to come and eat.
Seen this place many times but never stopped. Glad i checked it out. Did a Italian meal which was two steps above regular. Pleasant protected outdoor seating was available. Staff was very knowledgeable on menu items,
This place was amazing! The food was phenomenal! The waitress was by far the friendliest, most informative and personable waitress over had in ages. Deserved way more then what we gave her for sure and we gave her a lot! My bf brought me here for Valentines Day and it was so good...had enough left over to bring home for two more meals. The bathroom was immaculate. This is a nee favorite spot for us for sure...cant wait to try the pizza
This was the best pizza we have had since moving to CT, their gluten free pizza was especially great!! We came here to celebrate my birthday week. The restaurant was really spacious with big comfy booths/tables so you didn’t feel crammed next to strangers The service was really quick, but the food was super high quality and tasted delicious. Our server Kim did such a fantastic job, she even brought a separate little dish of ice cream for my wife since none of their on-menu desserts were gluten free that way I could have a lava cake but my wife could safely have dessert with me! And she even brought it out with a candle so that I could make a wish, truly a very thoughtful gesture and was so appreciated by us. We will absolutely be back here at Joey Garlic’s again!
So good!! Over sized portions so you will have leftovers unless you share a meal or come super hungry! 10/10!!
Wow this place is amazing! Can we talk the owners into putting one in the Fort Worth area! I believe the bartenders name is Spencer and he had perfect customer service! Fast and friendly as he was hustling all the time! Old fashioned was made to perfection! I had never had the pork cutlet parmigiana before so that’s what I ordered! It was absolutely delicious! So delicious I had to find a recipe so I could make in Texas! It had 3 cutlets with pasta and sauce on the side! Did I mention the salad? So fresh, cool and crisp! Every time I in the area, I will be back!
We have never had a bad experience here. We usually come to celebrate Good report cards as it's one of our sons favorite restaurants. The eggplant fries are amazingly addictive, the Detroit style pizza is great, and the penne alla vodka is one of the best non home made versions in the state. The sandwiches are huge too. We'll continue to enjoy our trips here every few months!
Location
-
150 Kitts Ln, Newington, CT 06111, United States Hotline: +1 860-372-4620
Welcome to Joey Garlic's Newington, a delightful culinary gem nestled in the heart of Newington, Connecticut. Located at 150 Kitts Ln, this restaurant has quickly become a favorite among locals and visitors alike, renowned for its authentic Italian cuisine and warm, welcoming atmosphere. With a mission to bring a taste of Italy to New England, Joey Garlic's offers a diverse menu that caters to every palate, featuring everything from classic pasta dishes to delectable grinders.
One of the standout items that has captured the hearts—and appetites—of patrons is the eggplant parmesan grinder, hailed by customer ryan anderson for its exceptional flavor and texture. Such praise only hints at the overall quality that patrons can expect throughout the menu. From hearty servings of pasta, reminiscent of home-cooked meals from an Italian family, to memorable pizzas that leave a lasting impression, the dishes at Joey Garlic's stand a cut above conventional Italian fare.
Customer reviews consistently highlight the generous portion sizes and friendly service. Olivia Fantasia, a frequent diner, appreciates the sizable meals, although she advises that some dishes, like the broccoli and cheddar soup, may lean towards the mild side. This small critique does not overshadow the overall satisfaction diners experience, as most leave with happy hearts and full bellies.
The ambiance at Joey Garlic's enhances the dining experience, thanks to pleasant outdoor seating and spacious booths that invite relaxation. Henry Gregory's recent visit exemplified this comfort, as he indulged in an Italian meal that was notably elevated from the typical restaurant offering. The attentive staff further enriches this culinary journey, with servers who are knowledgeable about the menu and eager to assist diners in making choices tailored to their tastes.
A special mention goes to the service excellence exemplified by Kim, one of the many dedicated staff members. Rey Bennett's birthday celebration featured this warm hospitality alongside a fantastic meal, proving that at Joey Garlic's, it's not just about the food; it’s about creating memorable experiences. The little touches, like accommodating dietary restrictions and special requests, are testaments to the restaurant's commitment to exceptional service.
If you find yourself in Newington, do yourself a favor and stop by Joey Garlic's. Whether you're in the mood for a romantic evening out or a casual meal with friends, this restaurant guarantees a delightful experience. Just be sure to book ahead, especially on weekends, as this local favorite has a loyal following that keeps it busy. As for me, I eagerly await my next visit to dive into more of Joey Garlic's offerings, with the pizza topping my must-try list on my return!